Even though we do not sell our own branded private label products so product reviews don’t matter, store reviews are still a very important metric in an Amazon business. Store reviews influence customer trust, buy box rotation, and overall account performance. Many sellers overlook how impactful reviews are, but they play a massive role in how Amazon evaluates you as a seller.
Why Store Reviews Matter
Store reviews improve multiple parts of your Amazon operation:
- Buy Box Share
Amazon is more comfortable sharing the buy box with sellers who have strong, consistent feedback. - Customer Trust
A customer is more likely to buy from a seller with a high rating and a large number of reviews. - Account Health and Stability
Good reviews indicate reliability. This helps Amazon view you as a low risk seller. - Conversion Rates
Even if you are priced competitively, having a small amount of reviews can cost you sales.
Unlike product reviews, store reviews represent your performance as a seller. They measure fulfilment quality, customer service, order accuracy, dispatch reliability, communication and overall professionalism.
Why Customers Rarely Leave Reviews
One of the biggest challenges is that only a very small percentage of Amazon customers leave seller feedback. Rough estimates suggest that less than 1 percent of customers leave a seller review. Many customers simply do not bother unless they have had a negative experience.
Negative experiences trigger more reviews than positive experiences, the good thing is though, you can remove negative reviews by requesting removal next to the negative review under the actions drop down, most of the time Amazon removes these!

Because the default Amazon process does not encourage reviews, you need an automated system
How to Increase Your Store Reviews
The most reliable method is using a review request tool. This is where SageMailer becomes extremely valuable.
SageMailer is a simple and highly effective software designed to send automated review request messages to your customers. It uses Amazon-approved messaging templates to request seller feedback and product reviews.
What SageMailer Does
- Sends a customised message after the customer receives their product
- Uses templates you can edit to match your tone
- Automates the entire review request process
- Ensures every order receives a review request at the optimal time
- Stays within Amazon’s communication guidelines
Free Trial
SageMailer offers a free trial that allows you to send up to 300 review requests at no cost. This is more than enough to see results immediately.
Pricing
After the free tier, the pricing is based on the number of orders you process. The more you sell, the higher the plan, but the price is extremely affordable compared to the benefit of increasing seller feedback.
Why SageMailer Is Worth It
For such a low monthly cost, increasing your seller reviews by even a small percentage can:
- Increase your buy box share
- Improve your store credibility
- Strengthen your account
When you look at the return on investment, SageMailer pays for itself very quickly.

Final Thoughts
Store reviews matter. They affect buy box rotation, customer trust and the overall health of your Amazon business. Because customers rarely leave reviews on their own, you need a system that encourages feedback without breaking Amazon rules, which is where Sagemailer comes in.
If you want your account to grow, strengthen your seller profile and maximise your buy box share, increasing your store reviews should be a priority.